18th Novemeber 2026
BOWRAL AND DISTRICT HOSPITAL
TEMPORARY SPEAKER (Mr Mark Hodges): The question is that the House take note of the petition.
Mrs JUDY HANNAN (Wollondilly) (13:41): I commend the petition concerning establishing a cancer treatment infusion centre at Bowral and District Public Hospital to this House. I bring this issue to the State Parliament through both a paper and ePetition that cannot be physically combined but represent over 14,400 signatures. Community groups, Public Health First, the Bowral Country Women's Association and Bowral‑Mittagong Rotary have tirelessly campaigned for a cancer treatment option at Bowral hospital for over a decade. I recognise Peter Edwards, Meggan Harrison and especially Edna Carmichael, who is in the gallery today. They stood in rain, hail and shine to get this petition up.
A cancer treatment and infusion centre would be provided at Bowral and District Hospital to allow equity in the local population's access to cancer treatments in my electorate. Cancer, as we know, is the big silent killer. There are many charities and days recognising all sorts of cancers, but we do not consider that patients fighting cancer often deal with high amounts of radiation and chemotherapy and need to be given comfort when they receive treatment. Modern cancer treatment centres are usually built with a dozen or so chairs and administered by doctors and nursing staff who treat patients with rare diseases and cancers that need specialist treatment. Statistics show that Wollondilly and the Southern Highlands areas have the same number of cancer patients as areas such as Bankstown, but we have no public cancer treatment centre.
We need to start investing in services for the patients at Bowral hospital and reinforcing the great work done at our regional public hospitals. It is not a matter of either/or—the existing care at the public-private partnership with Ramsay in Bowral and the facilities in mega hospitals in Campbelltown and Liverpool are needed, but we also need cancer services in our regional public hospitals. In 2025 over 2,000 of my constituents were cancer patients. Some 1,600 were seen at Liverpool and Campbelltown public hospitals—over an hour travel away. Additionally, another 330 public patients were seen at Southern Highlands Private Hospital. The demand is clearly there now and into the future. The absence of a cancer treatment at Bowral hospital puts pressure on services at the other hospitals in the area.
Bowral is home to a growing number of ageing residents and key workers, and it is near the urban sprawl areas on the peri-urban fringe of Sydney. Residents do not consider the distance they need to travel to access essential health services that provide them with a chance to survive. The electorate is serviced by an unreliable diesel rail service and hardly any bus alternatives. Our taxi service has ceased operating, so transport needs to be provided by families. Sick and elderly residents have contacted my office raising concerns about the transport barriers to attending medical appointments and cancer treatment and infusion. Cancer treatment requires many trips per month. I know of patients who stood on Campbelltown station after their chemotherapy, waiting for a train to go home to Bowral; no train came and they wondered how on earth they would get there.
An investment in physical cancer treatment services, staff and equipment would greatly improve the quality of life of patients and their families and carers. I know that IPTAAS, the Isolated Patients Travel and Accommodation Assistance Scheme, is available for patients travelling long distances, reimbursing travel and accommodation costs. But a permanent cancer care centre in Bowral represents health investment in outcomes rather than the bandaid solution of reimbursing out-of-pocket expenses. We have been let down by previous governments despite the completion of the Bowral and District Hospital stage one and two upgrades to modernise the hospital.
We still lack cancer treatment services. Please not let that happen again. This current arrangement is for the adjacent private hospital to provide treatment to some of the patients, but only one in three patients are treated at the public hospital. In 2015 and 2017 the need and scope for the 12-bed cancer treatment and infusion centre was initially included in stage one of the hospital refurbishment and associated 10‑year clinical services plan. Research has shown demand for chemotherapy, infusion, urology, stroke, cardiology, complex care, mental health and drug and alcohol treatments, women's health and ear, nose and throat clinics.
Clearly, my constituents are following through on earlier identified cancer treatment needs that are exacerbated by the changing population demographics and remain unfunded by the State Government a decade later. Please do not let this Government let them down again. I commend this petition to the House and the New South Wales Government. A cancer treatment and infusion centre at Bowral and District Hospital has my overwhelming support. I suspect I will be supported by the member for Goulburn, whose constituents also use this hospital.
Mr GREG WARREN (Campbelltown) (13:46): I begin by acknowledging everyone who signed the petition for their advocacy and their passion about this important issue. I acknowledge my good friend the member for Wollondilly, whom the people of Wollondilly are lucky to have. Not a day goes by in this place when I do not see the member for Wollondilly making representations passionately on behalf of her community. As a neighbouring colleague, I enjoy working with her. The petition reflects a question facing all governments: How do we ensure that essential services keep pace with growing and changing communities?
I acknowledge the reference by the member for Wollondilly to the hospital upgrades 10 years ago, which would have been the perfect time to establish a treatment centre. But the situation confronting her community now points to the question facing all governments. It is particularly important across Wollondilly, Wingecarribee and south-west Sydney, because cancer treatment is highly specialised. It also depends on a person's diagnosis and individual circumstances. Their care may involve medical oncology, haematology, surgery, chemotherapy, immunotherapy, radiotherapy, pathology, medical imaging, pharmacy, allied health, specialist nursing, rehabilitation and psychosocial support.
The treatment centres in my electorate of Campbelltown service much, if not all, of our entire region, extending to Wollondilly. The point the member made about transportation continues to be an issue for the people of Wollondilly. I know Transport for NSW has a strong concentration there. The South Western Sydney Local Health District provides specialist oncology services at Liverpool, Macarthur, Bankstown and other areas into the highlands. Its broader cancer service includes oncology consultation, surgery, radiotherapy, chemotherapy, palliative care, haematology, cancer genetics and psychology services. The Macarthur Cancer Therapy Centre at Campbelltown Hospital, for example, provides oncology consultations, chemotherapy, radiation treatment, and allied health and support services for adult patients from Macarthur, Wollondilly and Wingecarribee.
While cancer services continue to support patients, I do recognise, as I have previously, that travel can be a barrier for many residents in Wollondilly and Wingecarribee in the Southern Highlands. A patient transport service operated by Cancer Council NSW provides an element of support for the people of the Southern Highlands who need to travel to appointments at the Macarthur Cancer Therapy Centre or who need to see a doctor or specialist. For members who may not be aware, the New South Wales Government also provides financial assistance to eligible patients who are required to travel outside their local area to access cancer treatment through the Isolated Patients Travel and Accommodation Assistance Scheme.
A proposal for a new set-up must consider and assess things like the projected number and clinical profile of patients, the availability of oncologists and haematologists, access to diagnostics, medicine preparation and storage, clinical governance, and connections to emergency and inpatient care. It must also examine whether a service can be staffed and sustained over the long term. The assessment needs to be given due consideration. That does not close the door on future improvements, which I sincerely appreciate, given the geographical location of my electorate. I understand the issues confronting affected communities. Decisions should be guided by evidence, clinical advice and very careful planning to ensure that they are fit for purpose.
The people of the Southern Highlands deserve care that is compassionate and convenient. Above all, they deserve care that is safe, clinically appropriate and sustainable. I am delighted to say that the Government will continue to work towards finding that balance. I end where I began, by thanking the member for Wollondilly for bringing the petition before the House. I also thank the community for signing it and for their passionate advocacy. It is sincerely appreciated.
Dr JOE McGIRR (Wagga Wagga) (13:51): It is a great privilege to say a few words in support of this petition. I acknowledge those who have signed the petition and also my good friend and colleague the member for Wollondilly for introducing it before the House. I particularly acknowledge Edna Carmichael, who is in the gallery, for her efforts. Having collected signatures for petitions, I know that collecting 10,000 is hard yakka. Edna and her team have done an outstanding job. I make a few comments about this issue because it is a matter of health care, and it is a matter of regional health care, which I advocate for strongly. I am pushing my rural health action plan on the Government. The plan is about getting many services closer to where people need them, particularly for cancer services and cancer treatment.
I have been a clinician; I was an emergency doctor. We used to treat cancer patients in little cubicles at Wagga Wagga Base Hospital back in the day. It was very primitive, but that was all we had. Otherwise, people had to go to Sydney. People would go from Wagga Wagga to Sydney for six weeks to get radiotherapy treatment at the Jean Colvin Hostel and it would break them. It would break them because cancer is a team game. To win the game against cancer, we need a team on board. We need doctors, nurses and specialists and we need drugs, radiotherapy and surgery. I get all that, but we also need family, community and financial support to make sure that someone is looking after our loved ones. I sing through the Cancer Council how important that support is.
Traveling for treatment is like New South Wales playing a State of Origin away game at Lang Park. We are not on our home territory. As a result, the outcomes do not get better. About 25 years ago, I remember a campaign in Wagga Wagga to establish a radiotherapy centre there, because otherwise people would have to travel for that service. We raised $6 million to establish that centre. There was no government support to build the building. The Government provided it with a radiotherapy licence, but the community's commitment to getting radiotherapy close to home was so strong that that is what happened. That is also what the petitioners are talking about: making sure that people have access to cancer treatment in their community, close to home and their supports.
When that cancer centre was established, there was a lot of scepticism from the Government and elsewhere. People asked, "Why put one in the country?" Why establish it there?" They said, "Surely people can travel to the city." But people were not travelling to the city. There was evidence at that time that people were deciding not to have treatment rather than travel to Sydney. That is how difficult it is to face a cancer diagnosis, and things are no different now for many communities. We must ensure that our cancer services are as close to our communities as possible, and the petition asks for just that. According to the member for Wollondilly, more than 1,600 people have to travel extensive distances to get treatment without public transport. They receive treatment in large, fancy centres, but they are away from the support of their community.
That issue came up in the inquiry of the Select Committee on Remote, Rural and Regional Health, which I chaired, in which we heard from the Bowral community about access to cancer services. Again, it comes back to that key issue: Communities should be able to access as much of their health treatment as close to their community as possible. While that is important, it is not just a feel-good thing; it matters for patient outcomes. It matters for their treatment results, it matters for their loved ones and it matters for their community. I am delighted to support this petition of the member for Wollondilly. I commend the community and everyone who signed the petition for their work. This petition makes a difference to people. It is very important. I commend the petition and its objects to the House and to the Government.
Mrs WENDY TUCKERMAN (Goulburn) (13:56): I support the petition, which calls on the New South Wales Government to establish a cancer treatment and infusion centre in the public hospital at Bowral. I thank the member for Wollondilly for introducing this petition. I also acknowledge our wonderful constituents, who have worked so hard to get those signatures so that we can debate the issue in the House. I have spoken to many of my constituents about it a number of times. I commend them for the work they do because they care about their community. This petition is about encouraging the Government to plan better for the future. We are seeing enormous development in the Southern Highlands, so we must ensure that we have the right services available for our community. That is the point that we make today.
The Government has failed, as other governments have failed in the past. There is no doubt about that. We have had many conversations about the clinical service plan and its lack of provision. I am very pleased that the Minister once again said that he looks forward to updating that clinical service plan, because we need to do that. We cannot wait any longer. We cannot have people who are suffering from cancer travelling many kilometres. That is one of the worst times in a person's life; there is no doubt about that. We must do our utmost to ensure that those services support healthy outcomes for patients. That is why the petition is so important. I acknowledge that the member for Campbelltown must be concerned about the number of patients from our area who are using his hospital. We need to get on top of those medical care issues because people in the regions seem to be missing out quite a bit.
I acknowledge the extraordinary work of the member for Wagga Wagga on the regional health service. We all support that because we live it every day, as do the poor regional patients who have to seek services in metro areas. I acknowledge the Government's public-private partnership in delivering some cancer services in Bowral, and I thank all the nurses and doctors who care for the patients who use those services, but there is more to it. The tertiary services are the important ones. These people are very sick and travelling those distances every day. It is horrendous to think about what they are going through. I beg the Government to seriously look at what is going on in the Southern Highlands. My electorate is a part of that, including the town of Moss Vale and the villages.
We have some services in Goulburn—there is no doubt about that—but there are so many people seeking these services. That is why it is important to make the Government aware, and this petition does that. We talk in the House about how important it is to our regional and rural communities. We need to make a change. We cannot continue the way things are. We have bipartisan support to ensure that this is happening, and we will assist the Government in any way we can. I hope that we do not need to get into government to get it right. We need to get it right. We need to do more work on what services are available to our communities.
I will talk about the issues around transport. The local taxi service is gone, which is such an important service to our community. What do we do now? How do we help these patients? These are questions that need to be looked at urgently. We cannot afford to wait. We need to have some action from this Government. We need to make sure that the services we require for communities across the Southern Highlands are being acted on and also taking pressure off the metropolitan services in Campbelltown and Liverpool. There is so much pressure on the system. We need to make sure that we are doing it better. I support the petition.
Mr MATT CROSS (Davidson) (14:01): I support the petition and acknowledge those in the gallery who have come to Parliament House. I acknowledge the work of the member for Wollondilly in presenting this petition, which is not just any petition. It is a petition that got over 10,000 signatures, which is a big deal. In the work that we do as members, it is so important that we get the community behind us so that people know our advocacy is backed by the community. I am a cancer survivor myself. I often have denial about having gone through bowel cancer 2½ years ago, but it does stay with you. I know that the member for Wollondilly too is a cancer survivor. I pay tribute to her survival and her advocacy.
Many of those in the gallery are cancer survivors or know cancer survivors. I am sorry if anyone present has lost anyone to cancer. Cancer does not discriminate. We must do everything we can to make sure that we get treatment, and that is what this petition is all about. When I reflect on my journey of getting treatment, I know I was very lucky. I live opposite a railway station in Lindfield. On a Wednesday morning, I would wake up and get the train. It would take 10 minutes to get to the North Shore Health Hub in St Leonards. I would walk to the location of the cancer treatment. It took 10 minutes to get to cancer treatment. For many who are undergoing treatment, they can drive themselves to cancer treatment but they cannot drive themselves home from it.
I was lucky in that the Northern Sydney Local Health District has good cancer statistics for survival, which is due to the close location to access treatment. That is an important point to make. That is why we need to do everything we can in other parts of New South Wales so that people have access to treatment in their local communities, which is exactly what this petition is about. I highlight point 2 in particular, which says:
Recognise that residents have to travel long distances out of the area for diagnosis and treatments.
For many people, that can sometimes be a step too far. It is hard enough just getting the treatment, but it is harder that you actually have to travel. That is why this petition is so important. Leadership is about solving problems. To the credit of the member for Wollondilly, instead of just suggesting that the problem is here, she also has a solution. That is where point 3—which is really powerful—comes in. It says:
Recognise that the Public Bowral and District Hospital has both the scope and space within the precinct for a cancer and rare diseases centre.
That is a very important point. I will not go into the details of my advocacy in this place, but I think it is common knowledge—or should be common knowledge—that you must be a squeaky wheel in this place if you want things done, no matter whether in government, in opposition or on the crossbench. If a member sits silently and hopes that the government of the day will deliver things without the member needing to advocate, then they are probably in the wrong business. Every member needs to be a squeaky wheel here. Getting the community behind her with a petition to say, "We actually have a solution to this problem," is something that the member for Wollondilly has done. I offer my deep thanks to her for that.
Much of the advocacy I do is through written questions. The aim of written questions, like this petition, is to get Ministers to know personally that something is an issue. They have many issues on their desks. They have to respond and get advice from their departments, and that is exactly what has happened here. The letter from the Minister gives a lot of hope. In particular, the Minister has advised that the district regularly reviews population projections and that he is getting advice in his office about the feasibility study for reviewing it. It is a step in the right direction. We need to keep advocating for it. This petition today is not the end of the advocacy; it is the continuation of the advocacy. I know that the member for Wollondilly will keep advocating. The member for Wollondilly has a strong supporter for this facility in the member for Davidson on Sydney's North Shore, just like the member for Goulburn. I thank all the petitioners and support this petition in the House.
Mr RYAN PARK (Keira—Minister for Health, Minister for Regional Health, and Minister for the Illawarra and the South Coast) (14:06): In response: I acknowledge all who have contributed on this matter, particularly the member for Wollondilly. Members from both sides of the Chamber know that she is a formidable advocate. People are lucky to have her as their local member of Parliament. Getting 10,000 residents to support a petition is no mean feat. Having done it once in my life before, in 2012, in relation to a hospital in my own patch, I know the challenge and the importance of it. As their Minister, I want the petitioners to know that this is something the Government is seriously looking at. The desire for more care, particularly for cancer, to be delivered locally is extremely important to me. The member for Davidson has talked about his own cancer journeys. The Deputy Premier has talked about hers, as has the Minister for Industrial Relations at times. These journeys reflect the journeys of many people in our own communities.
Providing that care as close to home as possible is important. We are in the process of looking at the feasibility study and the way in which we might be able to make that a reality. I cannot make an announcement on that today, other than to say that we are carefully examining the feasibility study, what it will mean for the rest of the hospital, and how imaging services and other services will work within that environment. People should rest assured that that is something my office and the department are engaging in. From what the local member has said, I understand that public patients can currently access the chemotherapy and haematology services through the Southern Highlands Cancer Centre located next to the district hospital. But I also recognise that, while that is without any out‑of‑pocket expenses, it does not cover all of the cancer treatment and services. I assure the petitioners that I am aware that that is not the end of the road; I am just making that point.
The way in which services are networked is a strength of the local health system in New South Wales. It means that not every service is available at every hospital, but I give members a commitment that I have an intent to try, wherever feasible, to make services as close to home as we possibly can. I thank everyone who has advocated for that. They should rest assured that their Minister is looking at it. I thank the member for Wollondilly for her advocacy, as well as other members who have spoken in debate, for not only sharing their passion and interests but also lending their advocacy to this important issue.
Mrs JUDY HANNAN (Wollondilly) (14:09): In reply: I thank all members who contributed to debate. The member for Campbelltown listed all the services that are missing in Bowral, which was lovely. He knows what happens in Campbelltown. The member for Wagga Wagga talked about cancer treatment being a team effort and the impact of not having family close by. The member for Goulburn talked about how much we need a cancer treatment and infusion centre at Bowral. We actually needed it 10 years ago but we definitely need it now. The member for Davidson is a survivor. He was lucky; it took 10 minutes for him to get to the hospital. A man in my electorate who lived 250 kilometres from Bowral hospital had to get up at 6.00 a.m. to hopefully catch a train that would hopefully get him to his treatment, and he got home at 6.00 p.m. Ten minutes to hospital would have been magic for him.
I also thank the Minister for always having an open door. I will continue to henpeck him. The supporters in the gallery have literally stood in the rain, hail and snow—just about—in Bowral. They are very brave and I spoke about them in a community recognition statement last night. It is interesting because I still do not think people can grasp how far away the Wollondilly electorate is from Sydney. We are as large as the entire metropolitan area. Our people travel for their cancer treatment. Some 330 go to the private hospital while 1,600 travel. We travel further than the entire metropolitan area to get our treatment. I will continue to henpeck. Supporters in the gallery should rest assured that I will keep going at it. I thank them all very much for their hard work.
Petition noted.
TEMPORARY SPEAKER (Mr Mark Hodges): I shall now leave the chair. The House will resume at 2.30 p.m.